Review: Cabot Cheese – Pepper Jack Light & 50% Reduced Fat Sharp, Cheddar

by Kimberly Hickok

I am a big fan of Cabot products. Cabot Creamery is a co-op made up of dairy farms. Co-ops are owned and operated by their members, so basically the dairy farmers and their families own Cabot. Their butter, sour cream and cheese are staples in my fridge.

When Cabot contacted me asking if I would be willing to sample their light cheese, I jumped at the chance. For the record, I am not a Cabot employee and am not being compensated by them – apart from the samples they sent.

I also need to let you know that I am not a fan of anything that’s light, low-fat, no fat, no sugar – well, you get the picture. So when Cabot asked if I would sample some of their light products, I kept an open mind. After all, I love their other products so how bad could this be?
We received two 8 oz. blocks of cheese – Pepper Jack light and the 50% reduced fat, sharp cheddar. We sampled the cheese three ways – 1) sliced with crackers, 2) melted on bread, and 3) in mac and cheese.

Sliced with crackers
We tried the Pepper Jack first. We all agreed that the taste was great but the texture was a little rubbery. We then moved on to the cheddar. Much better consistency and really good flavor. For good measure, we compared it with Cabot’s Seriously Sharp (because we always have it in the fridge!) and to make sure we were doing as close to an apples to apples comparison as possible.
Conclusion: If serving with crackers, fruit or just to snack on, I would recommend it.

Melted on bread
One of our favorite snacks is cheese toast. So a sampling of light cheese wouldn’t be complete without melting it on some Tuscan bread. Again, the flavor was great and both cheeses melted really well as you can see below. The mouth feel was a wee bit ‘plasticky’ but if you’re doing the low-cal thing, this can be easily overlooked. In our opinion, flavor and meltiness (is that a word?), trump the slightly different texture.
Conclusion: Grilled cheese lovers will definitely not feel like they are sacrificing anything when grilling with this cheese.

Pictured in the foreground is the Pepper Jack Light – super melty!

Mac –n- cheese
The last time I made mac-n-cheese, I used Cabot’s Seriously Sharp and Jalapeno cheese. I decided to use my recipe and replace it with the reduced fat version of both cheeses. The recipe calls for making a white sauce and adding shredded cheese. The sauce tasted great but it just didn’t melt right after baking with the macaroni. Weird. I can only attribute it to their not being enough ‘fat’ in the cheese.
Conclusion: I would not recommend using low or reduced fat for dishes like mac-n-cheese or a gratin.

Final thoughts
I am still a fan of any dairy product that’s not reduced or low fat – especially Cabot products. That being said, I would definitely snack on the low fat cheese and use it for melting but maybe not so much in a sauce.

You may also like


Wendy September 28, 2012 - 12:16 pm

Thanks so much, Kim! We really appreciate your taking the time to cook and review our Light Cheddars. And I LOVE your photo. That looks so good! Can I pin it to our Pinterest board?

Kim September 28, 2012 - 12:50 pm

My pleasure. I really love your products. Feel free to Pin away!

Kimversations Thanks Giveaway! » Kimversations November 22, 2012 - 1:23 pm

[…] blogging opportunities have come my way. I’ve had a ball reviewing cheese, touring dairy farms, visiting NY wine country and attending store openings. I’m even reviewing […]

janicedoty November 23, 2012 - 10:15 am

Kim–We love the Cabot cheeses as well–practically the only cheeses in our drawer! (for whatever reason they don’t have the mozarella in Cabot here)

We used the 50% light cheddar in a recipe last night and it did well–perhaps because it was melted with milk on the stove top and then used in a Broccoli Casserole? Not sure why it worked but so glad it did!

Albany Jane April 1, 2014 - 12:31 pm

I dig their pepperjack and sharper flavored cheddars. Melted on toast (or any form of melty cheese) is a major weakness for me!

Candace @ Cabot April 2, 2014 - 7:08 am

Thanks for your thorough review and your excellent explanation of Cabot’s cooperative ownership. Our farm families really appreciate your support!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More